From: dlrenfro@gateway.net (Dave L. Renfro)
Subject: Re: Worms
Date: 18 May 2000 16:56:39 -0400
Newsgroups: sci.math
Summary: [missing]
Dan Goodman
[sci.math Thu, 18 May 2000 00:59:52 +0100]
wrote
> I've been looking at the following problem, which I've been told
> is a hard research problem. I was wondering if anyone can tell
> me where the current research has got to or provide me with some
> links if there any. The problem is to find a set of minimum
> measure such that any rectifiable (2d) curve of length 1 can be
> translated, rotated, reflected so that it lies within the set.
> Apparently, you can construct a set of zero measure that will
> accomodate any polygonal curve, but someone has proved that the
> set must have strictly positive measure for all rectifiable
> curves. Any idea how these were proven? Thanks,
>
> Dan Goodman
>
> p.s. the subject is "worms" because the original problem was
> stated with the word worms instead of rectifiable curves of
> length 1.
See Chapter 7 ("Besicovitch and Kakeya sets") of Falconer [5],
especially 7.4: "Generalizations" on pp. 106-109. For instance,
Theorem 7.9 on page 103 says that any subset of R^2 containing a
line in every direction must have Hausdorff dimension 2. The
result is due to Davies [4], who proved the slightly stronger
result that any subset of R^2 containing a line segment in every
direction (there does not have to be a positive lower bound on the
lengths of these segments) must have Hausdorff dimension 2.
[Indeed, as Falconer points out, if dim(E) < 2, then E intersects
all lines, in all but a 1-measure zero set of directions, in a set
of 1-measure zero.] I believe it is still an unsolved problem,
the Kakeya Conjecture, as to whether there exists a set in R^n
(n > 2) with n-measure zero containing a line segment in every
direction. [See Bourgain [2], Green [11], and Wolff [9] [17] for
some recent work on this question.]
In the opposite direction Besicovitch (1919) constructed a compact
set in R^2 with 2-measure zero containing a line segment in every
direction. Various similar results have been proved over the
years. For example, Davies [4] constructed a set in R^2 of
2-measure zero containing a translate of every polygonal arc,
and Marstrand [7] constructed in each R^n a set of Hausdorff
dimension 1 containing every congruent copy of any preassigned
countable collection of lines. [Keep in mind that there are
continuum many such congruent copies when n > 1.]
Marstrand [8] proved that given any n-measure zero set E in R^n
(n > 1), there exists a C^infinity curve of length one having
no congruent copy in E. Note that any C^infinity curve--indeed,
any C^1 curve--is rectifiable. [In fact, Marstrand proves that
every non-empty open connected subset D of R^n contains a
C^infinity curve which cannot be transformed into a subset of
E by an invertible analytic mapping from D into R^n.] Falconer [5]
(bottom of page 107) mentions this as solving the 'worm problem',
although Marstrand [8] doesn't appear to use this term. It seems
that the term 'worm problem' is due to Leo Moser. See Finch [10]
for more on the worm problem. Finch gives 36 references, many of
which are not among those I give below.
A helpful beginning expository paper is Cunningham [3]. Thomas
Wolff (CalTech) has recently written several papers on these
matters. Of these papers, I would recommend looking at
Wolff [9] [17], which contains 58 references. Other papers
that might be of interest are Bourgain [2] and Green [11].
For the Baire category analog of a Nikodym set, see Bagemihl
and Humke [1], Humke [6], and Steprans [15].
[1] Frederick Bagemihl and Paul Humke, "Rectifiably ambiguous
points of planar sets", J. Australian Math. Soc. (A) 20)
(1975), 85-109.
[MR 51 #14004; Zbl 305.04005]
[2] J. Bourgain, "On the dimension of Kakeya sets and related
maximal inequalities", Geom. Funct. Anal. 9 (1999), 256-282.
[MR 2000b:42013; Zbl 930.43005]
[3] F. Cunningham, "Three Kakeya problems", Amer. Math. Monthly
81 (1974), 582-592.
[MR 50 #14497; Zbl 286.52009]
[4] R. O. Davies, "Some remarks on the Kakeya problem", Proc.
Cambridge Phil. Soc. 69 (1971), 417-421.
[MR 42 #7869; Zbl 209.26602]
[5] Kenneth J. Falconer, THE GEOMETRY OF FRACTAL SETS, Cambridge
Tracts in Mathematics 85, Cambridge University Press, 1985.
[MR 88d:28001; Zbl 587.28004]
[6] Paul Humke, "Baire category and disjoint rectilinear
accessibility", J. London Math. Soc. (2) 14 (1976), 245-248.
[MR 56 #563; Zbl 342.26005]
[7] J. M. Marstrand, "An application of topological transformation
groups to the Kakeya problem", Bull. London Math. Soc. 4 (1972),
191-195.
[MR 47 #4234; Zbl 248.28017]
[8] J. M. Marstrand, "Packing smooth curves in R^q", Mathematika
26 (1979), 1-12.
[MR 81d:52009; Zbl 403.28008]
[9] Thomas H. Wolff, "Recent work connected with the Kakeya
problem", pp. 129-162 in Hugo Rossi (ed.), Prospects in
Mathematics (Invited talks on the occasion of the 250'th
anniversary of Princeton University, 1996.), American
Math. Society, 1999. (This paper is on-line. See [15].)
[MR 2000d:42010. This was a featured review, which even
non-math-sci-doc members can access at
;
The Zbl review not officially numbered yet, but you can find
it on-line by going to
.]
|---------------------|
| INTERNET REFERENCES |
|---------------------|
[10] Steven Finch, (a) "Moser's Worm Constant", (b) "Results
for Closed Worms", and (c) "Outcomes Corresponding to
Translation Covers".
(a)
(b)
(c)
[11] B. J. Green, "The Kakeya Problem", 78 page expository paper.
[12] Nets Hawk Katz, Izabella Laba, and Terence Tao, "An improved
bound on the Minkowski dimension of Besicovitch sets in R^3",
65 pages, to appear in Annals of Math.
[13] Nets Hawk Katz and Terence Tao, "A new bound on partial
sum-sets and difference-sets, and applications to the Kakeya
conjecture", 6 pages, submitted to Math Research Letters.
[14] Izabella Laba, "An improved bound on the Minkowski dimension
of Besicovitch sets in R^3" and "An improved bound on the
Minkowski dimension of Besicovitch sets in medium dimension".
[15] Juris Steprans, "A category analogue of a Nikodym set", on-line
construction in the link labeled "A partial solution to the
problem" at
[16] Terence Tao, (a) "Bochner-Riesz, Restriction, and Kakeya
estimates" and (b) "Besicovitch sets" [A java applet
giving one version of Besicovitch's construction.], (c) A
very detailed chart showing the relationships between
results and conjectures related to Kakeya and Nikodym sets
[See the link for "interconnections between various
conjectures in this family".], (d) "Restriction theorems and
applications", Lecture Notes for UCLA Math 254B, Spring 1999.
(a,c)
(b)
(d)
[17] Thomas H. Wolff, "Recent work connected with the Kakeya
problem" and "Lecture Notes for CalTech Math 191d-Topics in
Harmonic Analysis" Spring 2000.
Dave L. Renfro
P.S. On a personal note, you might be interested to know that
shortly after I began looking up these references--around
12 noon Central time--the Des Moines (Iowa) emergency sirens
came on. I had been hearing distant thunder and was thinking
of getting off-line and unplugging my computer if it got worse
but, until the sirens came on, I was not aware that a severe
storm and tornado was headed my way. I immediately turned on
my radio and heard that a tornado had been sighted less than
15 miles from where I live! Immediately ... Computer is shut
down, computer is unplugged from the wall, anything I
considered to be especially valuable that was near any of
my apartment windows (expensive math books, birth certificate
and SS card, etc.) was moved to the hallway, etc. The radio
reported strong hail, producing white-out conditions downtown
downtown, less than 2 miles from where I live, but I
never saw any hail. From what I could judge from the radio
reports the tornado came within about 12 or 13 miles of
where I live. However, at no time did I see any significant
wind. In fact, most of the time it was simply very dark
with light rain and almost no wind. After an hour or so
the situation appeared sufficiently safe for me to get back
on-line. I'm not sure what amount of damage has occurred in
the areas east to me because I've been absorbed with Kakeya
stuff since then (!). [This subject is somewhat related
to things I'm interested in. Because it's been about a year
since I last looked into what people are doing in this area,
responding to this post provided me with an excuse to see
what has been going on lately.]